Custom Cakes

Birthday? Anniversary? Corporate event? Wedding? Let Carousel Cakes handle the dessert!

SizeServesFudge,
Buttercream
Whipped Cream,
Red Velvet, Blue Velvet
Carrot, Napoleon,
Mousse Supreme
7" round
8" round
10" round
12" round
1/4 Sheet
1/2 Sheet
Full Sheet
6–10
10–15
14–18
25–35
15–25
35–50
75–100
18.00
26.00
32.00
50.00
38.00
65.00
90.00
20.00
31.00
35.00
55.00
42.00
72.00
100.00
21.00
n/a
36.00
n/a
60.00
110.00
145.00
  • Most fillings, buttercream flowers, confetti/sprinkles & Inscriptions are included in the above prices.
  • Choice of white, chocolate, red velvet, or carrot cakes.
  • Additional charge of $5.00 for different cake flavors layered on top of one another (not available side by side).

Choice of Fillings Available: Chocolate mousse, cream cheese, blackout pudding, raspberry, cherry, peach, blueberry, strawberry, pineapple, custard, lemon, fudge, apricot, peanut butter buttercream, strawberry buttercream, oreo buttercream, mocha buttercream, chocolate buttercream, whipped cream and cannoli. (Cannoli filling is an additional $5.00)

Choice of Frostings Available: Buttercream, fudge, sweet cream cheese, whipped cream, mocha buttercream, chocolate buttercream, ganache. (Ganache frosting is an additional $10.00) Choose inscription, color scheme, color of writing and color of buttercream flowers. Sugar flowers are additional cost depending on the size of the cake (ranging from $5.00-$30.00).

Specialty Decorated Cakes: All customers who wish to have a special design or drawing on their cake must supply a picture for the decorator to work from. Drawings and Special Decorations are an additional $25.00 & up depending on the difficulty. Drawings can only be drawn on 1/4 sheet cake or larger; on buttercream and fudge. Please note, we require 24 hours notice for custom writing on our cakes.

Cake Writing: Come in Monday-Friday and get writing on any in-stock cake while you wait; no need to place an order!

Edible Images Are Now Available! A great way to personalize your cakes! Bring in your own image, email us an image or choose from our selection of licensed characters! 
Click here for more info.


We do custom engagement and wedding cakes. Call us at (845) 627-2323 for prices on Special Occasion cakes.





Visit our Handling Tips page for important information about keeping your Carousel Cake fresh.


Critical Acclaim