Homestyle Pies

Carousel Cakes make a pie perfect for any occasion. A picnic dessert or a holiday treat, and anywhere in between.

Apple Pie

Best Seller! When it comes to this American classic, Grandma has nothing on us! Our apples are cooked to perfection and the seasoning is just right. It is also available in cherry and blueberry. (Sugar free pies are available.) (Also available as PAREVE, non dairy.)
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $12.50

Click here for delivery pricing.

Pumpkin Pie

The ideal mix of spices makes our pumpkin pie delectable. The perfect complement to your Thanksgiving dinner! (seasonal)
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $12.50

Click here for delivery pricing.

Apple Crumb Pie

Best Seller! We've baked delicious cinnamon apples in a flaky homemade cookie pie crust all topped with streusel crumbs. We'd recommend heating it up and add fresh whipped cream or ice cream to make it extra special!
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $12.50

Click here for delivery pricing.

Blueberry Crumb Pie

We've baked luscious blueberries in a flaky homemade cookie pie crust all topped with streusel crumbs. We'd recommend heating it up and add fresh whipped cream or ice cream to make it extra special!
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $12.50

Click here for delivery pricing.

Cherry Crumb Pie

We've baked delicious sweet cherries in a flaky homemade cookie pie crust all topped with streusel crumbs. We'd recommend heating it up and add fresh whipped cream or ice cream to make it extra special!
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $12.50

Click here for delivery pricing.

Peach Crumb Pie

We've baked tasty cling peaches in a flaky homemade cookie pie crust all topped with streusel crumbs. We'd recommend heating it up and add fresh whipped cream or ice cream to make it extra special!
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $12.50

Click here for delivery pricing.

Pumpkin Cheese Pie

Best Seller! Our signature Thanksgiving dessert! We've taken our traditional pumpkin pie and made it extra special by resting it on a layer of our NY cheesecake. A must try! (seasonal)
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $15.00

Click here for delivery pricing.

Tollhouse Pie

We take our flaky cookie crust and fill it to the top with chocolate chip cookie dough, walnuts, and brown sugar. Served warm or at room temperature, this treat is definitely complemented by a scoop of ice cream.
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $13.50

Click here for delivery pricing.

Coconut Custard Pie

The secret to our creamy custard is in the eggs. From the freshest eggs to the perfect amount of coconut, this dessert is perfect at Thanksgiving or anytime.
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $12.50

Key Lime Pie

This perfect summer dessert is a combination of sweetened condensed milk and fresh keylime juice from Key West, Florida. The delicious pie filling is place in a graham cracker crust, making it a perfect ending to any meal.
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $13.50

Pecan Pie

We recommend you taste this sweet Southern specialty made with dark karo syrup, whole pecans, and a homemade crust. if you're really looking for the total combination, add a dollop of whipped cream or a scoop of ice cream when you serve it.
 

10" pie (serves 8-10): $15.00

Click here for delivery pricing.


Visit our Handling Tips page for important information about keeping your Carousel Cake fresh.


Critical Acclaim